Pretty but narrow
This is a very pretty boot and I was excited to get it. I own three other pairs of Old Gringo boots. Currently, I own the Old Gringo Ellie, Carissa (I had to stretch this pair), and Jaylene in an 8.5 I also have Lane Wind Walker Bootie in 8.5, two pairs of Corral in size 9, and Lariat in size 9. The Old Gringo Erin was a very pretty boot and I was excited to get it. When I first tried it on I thought it just needs to stretch. But, I compared the width of the sole to my other Old Gringo boots and the Erin was definitely more narrow across the ball of the foot. I considered stretching the boot but because of the stitching, I didn't think stretching would work. Sadly I chose to return the boot despite how pretty it was.